Edward Tufte’s The Cognitive Style of PowerPoint lobbies some legitimate criticisms. The medium of visual presentations has always been one that I have found difficult to approach, execute, or understand. I have routinely been confused by the formats, particularly the seemingly subjective aesthetic elements, which Tufte refers to as “Phluff” in reference to PowerPoint. Tufte scathingly criticizes much of the stylistic aspects of PowerPoint. I have always felt that a great deal of the effort put into manufacturing a PowerPoint is devoted to meaningless uses of templates, transitions and rules that limit content. The focus of this medium is on style that seems fundamentally flawed in delivering information. Tufte specifically critiques the inadequacy of PowerPoint in representing statistical graphs and data tables. Dense statistics deserve adequate representation that cannot be provided by a medium that limits the use of text. PowerPoint also necessitates the use of bullet points; virtually all that I have been taught about PowerPoint has stressed the need for conciseness and limited text. Any attempts to provide a dense body of information through text or images are fundamentally flawed in the medium of PowerPoint. The use of bulleted phrases and words rather than complete sentences might seem to condense information and cue the audience into the most important information. However, conciseness also eliminates a great deal of information, thereby sacrificing content (see Figure 1). The whole mission of the slideshow presentation is to provide the audience with the most important information, however I feel that in most cases it merely functions as a tool for the presenter to organize his or her thoughts and oversimplifies the information. Too often I have seen presenters looking at their own slides and I have been guilty of this myself. It is a medium I abhor and in short, Tufte provided evidence to ground my grievances against PowerPoint.
                                          Figure 1
0

Add a comment

Trap. The combination of the genres of trance and rap usually through sound mixing and editing, has become a staple of parties and festival shows. They share similar use of synth, heavy base and spoken words to create music.
When we talked in class about usability and the internet, it sounded like the conclusion as to what makes a usable website is simplicity. Creating a website to serve a very obvious purpose is the key to usability.
Every day we are faced with multiple typefaces: the good, the bad and the ugly. Some help us to read faster and more clearly, some to invoke a specific feeling or emotion, all the while persuading us to do something (or buy something).
... and how clashing implications continue to shape our reactions to these colors.

Depending on the region and cultural upbringing, one may have different connotations associated with the colors black, white, and red.
When talking about the ethics and rhetoric of data displays in class, I brought up the example of geographic information system (GIS) and their technique of interpolation.
"The Cognitive Style of Powerpoint" makes the assertion that:

The core ideas of teaching- explanation, reasoning, finding

things out, questioning, content, evidence, credible authority not patronizing

authoritarianism-are contrary to the cognitive style of PowerPoint.
When I first pulled out Tufte's packet on Power Point, it looked like one of the most boring texts on the planet. 30 pages on the style of Power Point? But as I read, I started to see his point and even found myself laughing at certain parts (talking about the “stupefied audience”).
Since media technology has advanced past the typewriter, the capabilities of visual, and eventually digital, rhetoric using images have grown exponentially. By appealing to different human attitudes and emotions, digital images have the ability of persuasion and gaining compliance alike.
Often referred to as graffiti, tagging, or more negatively as vandalism, street-art has been around for 40ish years as it was birthed in the 70 but only gained a real popularity in the mid-80’s.
Blog Archive
Contributors
Loading
Dynamic Views theme. Powered by Blogger. Report Abuse.