-->
Of the recent readings for this course, I feel most compelled to comment on the writings of Jakob Nielsen. I had heard of him before, touted as the leading expert of usability. A great deal of the discussion in class was devoted to some apparent contradictions between his ethos and one of his now defunct websites. However, I noticed contradictions on the very page we were asked to look at for class. For example, Nielsen advises designers to "conform to design conventions" by making links blue and to “change the color of visited links” as the ones in Figure 1 appear.  However, Figure 2 displays a series of links on the same page that appear as black text, giving no indication that they are in fact links. What’s more is that these links do not change color after they have been clicked, as the blue ones do.
The concerns of the article also seem somewhat subjective and dated, though it was updated within the last two years. For a top ten list of “egregious offenses against users,” such things as advertisements, pdf files and opening new windows seem like either minor inconveniences or simply not everyone’s cup of tea. Considering the work at hand, I am somewhat puzzled by Nielsen’s reputation as a usability guru. His advice strikes me as either blatantly obvious, subjective, or irrelevant. I do not see much insight.
Figure 2: un-highlighted links
Figure 1: Links following Nielsen's guidelines
     
 







0

Add a comment

Gutters, Technique, and Transitions
Judge by the Cover: Trap and Trance
Judge by the Cover: Trap and Trance
The Pervasiveness of Mickey Mouse
Seriously: A James Joyce Comic
Un-novel?
Gutter Space
Craigslist usability
Craigslist usability
Usability Nightmare: Hidden Login Links
Nielsen's Hypocrisies
Comics in Visual Rhetoric Class 2013
The Limitations of PowerPoint in Today's World
Red, White and Black=Target
Creme Brulee, Anyone?
Creme Brulee, Anyone?
Top 8 Mistakes Made in PowerPoint?
Lack of Usability: ESPN
The Cultural Significances of Black, White, and Red...
The Cultural Significances of Black, White, and Red...
Usability Blunders
Helping Hand of Another
Data Sets Displays and Cognates
(Y)OUR MAP IS WRONG
(Y)OUR MAP IS WRONG
Teaching and Engaging versus Marketing
Teaching and Engaging versus Marketing
Is pecha-kucha the future?
Is pecha-kucha the future?
Middle Schoolers, Pecha-Kucha and Edward Tufte
Understanding Visual Rhetoric in Digital Writing Environments.
Logos
Keep Calm and Do What, Now?
Transparency
Visual Rhetoric in Persuasive Digital Images
Visual Rhetoric in Persuasive Digital Images
black and white advertising
Kept My Locus
Street-art and Style
Street-art and Style
Black, White, and Red
Academic Videos
Problems with PowerPoint
Accidental Obscenity
Accidental Obscenity
Crocaducks and Duckatoos
Searching "Black, White, and Red"
The Double Meaning of Dali's Clocks
Snip. Snip. Snip.
Snip. Snip. Snip.
Ehses and the Antithesis that creates choices
Students and technical guidelines
Typeface Fail
Typeface Fail
Kress and van Leeuwan and Western Horseman
Kress and van Leeuwan and Western Horseman
Given, Ideal, New, Real
1
Misuse of Typefaces
Meta-Discourse on Composition and Visual Design
Over-analyzing typeface?
Over-analyzing typeface?
Why visual rhetoric has come to stay
Why visual rhetoric has come to stay
1
Understanding the Rhetorical Situation
Understanding the Rhetorical Situation
The Anatomy of Typefaces
The Anatomy of Typefaces
Does type font really sway an audience in all circumstances?
Typeface Choices
Typeface Choices
1
Cover Art as Rhetoric
Graffiti and Visual Rhetoric
Graffiti and Visual Rhetoric
Page Composition: Are Kress and van Leeuwen Correct?
Page Composition: Are Kress and van Leeuwen Correct?
Color Issues
Color Issues
Elementary Document Design
American Spi(ri)t
Let's get to work . . .
1
Lady Rhetorica says:
Blog Archive
Contributors
Loading
Dynamic Views theme. Powered by Blogger. Report Abuse.